• More
Back to PopWatch Home
EW Home

Carrie Ann Inaba blogs 'DWTS,' week 7

Apr 22, 2009, 02:20 PM | by Carrie Ann

Categories: 'Dancing With the Stars'

Carrie_ann_week7_2 What a week! All the tables turned, new leaders emerged, and the whole leader board got "a shaking up." And that is why I LOVE THIS SEASON! I knew it! I had a feeling all along that the season was going to be very interesting and highly competitive as we approached the end of the season. Let’s start with Chuck and Julianne. I am so happy for them that they finally had a breakthrough. I always felt that he had an ease of movement that if he engaged his spirit and confidence behind it -- along with the training and technique he could tackle if he set his mind to it -- that he could do well. It was as if he finally decided that he was just going to go for it -- no excuses. That is such a wonderful thing to watch. A real breakthough. And we got to experience it right there with him. Congratulations Chuck and Julianne!

I would have to say Tony and Melissa had wonderful night as well -- and Shawn Johnson and Mark Ballas too!. Melissa’s Argentine Tango was really something special. That was a VERY difficult routine. It was filled to the brim with steps and there was no room for error. With all the leg flicks and weight changes and intricate movements, if they had missed one step or weight change, there would have been a problem and there was no space to catch up. But what I was impressed with were Tony’s lifts. I knew that he really specializes in lifts, but that was a really nice showcase of lifts (which are acceptable in the Argentine Tango). I also want to add that Melissa was stunning in that outfit. She really took on a strong persona and pulled it off wonderfully.

Shawn Johnson and Mark did a fantastic cha-cha-cha. I read a lot of your comments and I see that a lot of you really get upset when she doesn’t get great scores. It's nice to see your support for her. But I think you don’t have to worry about that anymore. She also had a breakthrough. Until Monday night, she was having a bit of trouble really getting the characters of the dance and letting go and finding her freedom in the dance to express herself. I saw it on Monday night and I was so proud of her. I’m sure most of you out there must also feel like a proud parent when Shawn does well. It’s like she is growing up in front of our eyes. She is such a special person -- so professional, so mature, so focused, so strong, and so pure. Her precision is her best asset, but it has also held her back a bit from adding that level of performance. Shawn and Chuck both really stepped it up, and I bet we see even more of it as weeks go by. And she got her first 10! Congratulations Shawn!!! She said it was her first 10 ever -- even in gymnastics!

Gilles and Cheryl performed a Viennese Waltz and did a nice job with it -- but at this level we can see that the contestants' success will definitely depend on the dances they get to perform. We have great performers left, but they all have different styles of performing. I gave Gilles a correction about his posture that I hope he will work on, because at this point everyone has to really put their best foot forward. With this sort of competition and the level that everyone is performing at, there is no room for error. Those little things will separate the winner from the runner up, because we have some great contenders left.

Don’t worry, I’m not forgetting about Ty and Lil' Kim. Lil' Kim and Derek proved a really interesting point in this competition on Monday night, and I think they sent out a good message to everyone in general. They tried to impress Len -- or what they thought Len wanted -- by toning down her performance. But in doing so, Kim lost some of her special spark. This is a good lesson -- it is important to do what you do best and follow your own heart when making choices. It worked out well and I’m glad they survived -- this week Kim and Derek dropped quite far down the leader board and I was worried about them. But they are still in it and I think she’ll be back to herself next week, bringing back her inner tiger!

And Ty had a good week. But I think he was a bit intimidated after Chuck did so well. Sometimes it is so difficult to come after someone who really changes the energy in the room. I felt that he was a bit nervous. But he is still such a nice surprise in how far he has come with his dancing. His scores have been all over the place and they started out very low. He definitely specializes in the ballroom dances, where he can “hold on” as he said. Now that LT is gone, we’ll see who ends up on the bottom next week. It's going to be sad next week when someone goes home.

Lawrence was happy to go home, it seemed, so I’m happy for him. I guess he’s back to golf now. Good luck, LT!

Last night’s result show was filled with dancing. I am excited to see how the new dancers who are vying for a spot on the show will do as the weeks progress. We don’t have any voting power as judges -- this is all up to the audience vote. It’s really nice to see these kids having this opportunity. They all seemed like nice people and had different strengths, but on this show it takes a lot to be a professional. First of all, you have to be a great teacher -- you must be able to teach the steps and technique and then choreograph your numbers in a way that best displays your partner's talent and assets. You must be able to perform in a way that doesn’t outshine your celebrity partner but helps complement what he or she brings to the dance floor, and you need to be a strong guide and partner on the journey to the mirror ball. You also have to have your own star quality because, as we have seen, our dancers become stars in their own right. What it takes to make these celebrities shine is a lot more than just being a good dancer. It takes a certain type of person. You have to be strong and patient, creative and intelligent, and I really applaud our dancers for all that they do. Being a DWTS professional dancer is an incredible opportunity. Look at Julianne and Mark and Derek, who have gone on to record albums and are doing quite well. Our show is a wonderful opportunity for both dancers and celebrities to create even better futures for themselves and open doors in their careers that are quite amazing.

Also, NATASHA BEDDINGFIELD!  She performed the most incredible version of "Soulmate," which is my personal favorite song. I LOVE THAT SONG.  She is one heck of a singer. I loved the way she changed it up and the performance of Dimitry and Lacey was quite good. Lacey gets better and better with each performance. I loved watching her. And Dimitry is such a fine performer -- he's a bit shy, but a good partner for Lacey.

Our results show this week was jam-packed, but my favorite performance was the BURN THE FLOOR performance. I am in discussions to be a producer on that show as it heads to Broadway this summer. I saw the show in San Francisco a few weeks ago and loved it. (They are playing until next week, before they head on tour and then come to Broadway in the summer, so keep your eyes open and I hope you will all come out and support their show.) The dancers are beautiful and grew up all over the world. You'll see some fantastic dancing if you go. It will help you get through your summer without DWTS!

Finally, I just wanted to remind everyone that the auction for my "DWTS Experience" package at Clothes Off Our Back is coming to a close on May 1. So if you are interesting in coming to the show’s finale, you can bid on those tickets and the whole package. All the proceeds go to The Andrea Rizzo Foundation, which provides dance therapy for pediatric cancer patients and children with special needs. It’s a wonderful cause -- very dear to my heart -- and I just wanted to remind you that if you want to come to the show and get a beautiful dress and a diamond necklace, and some cute shoes, the auction is still going on.

Thanks for tuning in -- it’s getting exciting, isn’t it?!

Thanks for your comments as well.

Oh -- behind the scenes -- Sheila E. was there last night and came over and gave me a hug -- and it was a very exciting moment. I have been a fan of hers for a long time. She is an incredible percussionist and performer and the first star I met when I was young. She signed me an autograph on a piece of glass. She wrote backwards and I kept that glass for a long time…until one day, I had someone clean my house and she cleaned the glass and the autograph was gone when I got home. ; (

But I still have the memory. ;)

Have a great day -- summer is coming!!

Enjoy,
Carrie Ann

More on Dancing With the Stars:
Carrie Ann's blogs: Week 6, Week 5, Week 4, Week 3, Week 2
Annie Barrett's 'DWTS' elimination recap: Suited to a Tee
'DWTS': Season 8's Crazy Costume Watch!

diana Wed, Apr 29, 2009 at 05:29 PM EST

Dosen't matter anyway. TY IS WINNING, YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

birdsofafeather Tue, Apr 28, 2009 at 10:07 PM EST

I am a happy little bird tonight, Melissa and Ty are both continuing in the competition~~~~~~~~~~~ BUT LKim or Shawn should have gone tonight instead of Chuck, Chuck was getting his groove on~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Nikki Tue, Apr 28, 2009 at 03:48 PM EST

birdsofafeather, you are absolutely the most immature person on this entire website. Did I SAY Shawn deserved a perfect 30? NO. What I asked was why Carrie Ann wouldn't give her one even though she said she was flawless, so why don't you read my posts in their entirety before you start running your mouth off just because I'm a Shawn fan. I like her not only because she is a good dancer (which they have all said, regardless of her 'masculinity') but because she is an AMAZING 17 year old girl. Quit telling us its a FACT that she sucks because if it were she would not still be there getting good scores. If you know so much, why aren't you a judge? I've read all of your comments and it's obvious you like Melissa, WE ALL KNOW THAT, but stop talking smack about every other contestant and get a freaking life. You are rude and hostile and contribute absolutely nothing to the conversation other than a bunch of words in caps, did I ask YOU what Shawn needs for a 10 from CAI? NO! I asked Carrie Ann herself. GET OVER YOURSELF

DWTS Fan Mon, Apr 27, 2009 at 08:55 PM EST

Carrie, I can hardly wait for you to blog this week as I will post the same information. What is Samantha still doing on this show? She is annoying. She asks the dancers questions and then doesn't allow them to finish answering because she has to hog the conversation with her BIG mouth. Surely DWTS can do better at selecting a person that will fit in with Tom. Get RID of her!!!!!!!!

birdsofafeather Mon, Apr 27, 2009 at 04:47 PM EST

Nikki, you have nothing more to do with your time than to cry about the scores. Shawn won a gold medal yes, BUT that doesn't make her an automatic professional dancer, whick she is not!!!!!!!

I am threw with ALL OF the Shawn fans, THEY ARE STUPID ENOUGH to keep asking the same stupid questions even though they have been given the answers by judges and other viewers but you refused to listen to anyone who may have dance knowledge and would tell you why Shawn is not getting perfect 30's. She is toooooooo Masculine and her core is thick and she is not feminine!!!!!!! SHAWN IS NOT THE BEST DANCER PERIOD!!!!!!!! I refused to talk to you Shawn fans anymore because you are ignorant!!!!!!!!!!!

birdsofafeather Mon, Apr 27, 2009 at 04:41 PM EST

Shut up Connie, you are taking things out of context!!!!!!!! DON't tell me ever what to do, I won't listen to you! I am threw talking to you, you are ignorant!!!!!! I am not waisting my time on stupid folks!!! And Connie you are stupid!!!!!

Nikki Mon, Apr 27, 2009 at 08:05 AM EST

I agree with the others. I really want to know what Shawn and Mark have to do in order for you to give them a 10. You commented on the fact that she is 'technically flawless' and that the dance really 'came to life' yet you still give her a 9. The same score you gave to others who absolutely did NOT deserve it.

And, to all those people RIPPING Shawn apart because she's 'masculine' that compact, masculine, little body won an Olympic gold medal. Have you? I'm sure you haven't, because you have nothing better to do with your time than sit here and tear a 17 year old girl apart. Oh, and you do realize Shawn gets a LOT less practice time than everyone else because of her age, right?! Obviously we can all vote for whoever we want, but have some freaking class. If you want to rip people apart, how about the fact that Melissa has an extremely unfair advantage being a former DCC.

Keep it classy because they are in this TO HAVE FUN and they RESPECT EACH OTHER.

Connie Sun, Apr 26, 2009 at 09:35 PM EST

Hi birdsofafeather: Misty May wasn't short by any means, but she was muscular.

Anyways, as to the judges' scores for Shawn, speaking for myself, I was okay with her scores this week. She got her first 10, and I'm proud of her. Regardless of what you may think of her dancing, the girl has worked her heart out learning the dances. So I'm glad she's getting the scores she's getting.

As to the selection of the other talent of the show, if you have complaints you should try to contact the talent producers, or if it bothers you to that extent, no one is making you watch the show.

birdsofafeather Sun, Apr 26, 2009 at 11:00 AM EST

Hello Connie, Misty May was long and lean, HeHeHe. I was ONLY answering your questions since you couldn't seem to figure that out yourselves!!!!! YOU ALL KEEP ASKING WHY SHAWN DID NOT GET HIGHER SCORES ~~~~~~
LKim also should not even been on dwts. SHE IS STILL ON PROBATION from prison~~~~~ READ L Kim's Wiki page!!!!~~~~
What is the hell were the casting directors thinking??????

DWTS is really scrapping the bottom of the rotten apple barrel with some of the pros and the celebs~~~~

DWTS is a great show but pleeeeaaasee use better judgement with your pros morals and the celebs prison past~~~~~

Connie Sun, Apr 26, 2009 at 10:38 AM EST

birdsofafeather: One more thing, everyone has their own dancing styles. If all the celebrities who came on the show, had the same long and lean body type, then there would be a sameness to everything, in my opinion.

The great thing about this show is that it brings together celebrities from all different arenas with their own unique qualities. Some people may like them, some may not. It's all very subjective.

And speaking of masculine, Shawn is muscular and compact. She's not the only one of this type who has been on the show. Think Sabrina Bryan and Misty May Traynor (before she torE her ACL). Both women are pretty muscular as well.

Connie Sun, Apr 26, 2009 at 10:25 AM EST

birdsofafeather: Well, you're entitled to your opinion, so you don't vote for Shawn. Vote for Melissa and Gilles. That's the beauty of this competition, everyone can vote for who they want to win.

You may not like Shawn's dancing, but she has a strong fanbase who WILL vote for her.

No skin off my nose.

birdsofafeather Sat, Apr 25, 2009 at 04:18 PM EST

Connie: NO I am not a fan of two men dancing together as a couple!!!!

Shawn is not the best dancer, she is the best gymnist~~~~~~~~~

Shawn's fans kept asking why she was not getting better scores! SO I TOLD YOU! IF you don't want to hear the truth, THEN DON'T ASK! It is that simple!

I answered your question!!!!!

Shawn has a masculine movement about her, her core is very THICK, she moves like a man!~~~~~~~ This is the reason she will not win dwts!

The truth is Melissa and Gilles are the two best dancers this season!!!!
F A C T ! ! ! !

birdsofafeather Sat, Apr 25, 2009 at 04:14 PM EST

dancefan: bite me!!!!

I am not a Melissa fan, I am a FAN of AMAZING DANCING!!!!!

Yvonne Sat, Apr 25, 2009 at 01:24 AM EST

Why the slams on Carrie Ann? I can't believe the level of maturity showing in the comments. Come on people making these terrible comments about judgement. Don't you know that judges can be BOTH gorgeous and smart? Accept it will you, this is supposed to be fun.

Matt2 Sat, Apr 25, 2009 at 01:04 AM EST

Hey Carrie Ann, did you guys send out a mandate for greatness this week or what? The dances that needed to be elegant and beautiful; were, and the dances that required quicker, sharper energy, indeed delivered. Apparently on this season the judges get what they ask for, all the time. I'm sure you love it.
Two weeks ago Chuck and Julianne were struggling for a breakthrough. This week they tie for 3rd. Chuck went all out this week. He must realize with the horses in this race, it's going to require that type of effort from here on out.
Still, my fave of the night was Shawn and Mark. Mark put her to work in that Cha-Cha and it came out hot, fun, and flashy. And not to be left in the cold, Derek turned down the thermostat on Lil Kim's Rhumba while still producing heat! That acknowledged, the surprise has to be that less than 4 pts. separates #1 from #5. Lil Kim is my fave among them, but even I have to admit any of the remaining six are capable of winning the 8th season DWTS title.

dancefun Fri, Apr 24, 2009 at 05:02 AM EST

Wow, birdsofafeather, you fanatic Melissa fans are downright rude, disgusting, and annoying. Maybe that's typical for people who watch "Bachelor" show? You guys put down Gilles and now Shawn. I hope Melissa got voted off ASAP so that her nasty fans disappear ASAP. If a "Bachelor" dump won DWTS, it would be an insult to all Americans.

Connie Fri, Apr 24, 2009 at 04:34 AM EST

I think all the couples did their best Monday night and I enjoyed all their performances.

For me, the best routine of the night was Shawn and Mar's cha cha cha. It was really fun to watch and Shawn was working those hips of hers! They both looked as though they were having a blast! :) I'm so proud that she got her first 10. I've got a feeling that this is just the beginning!

Connie Fri, Apr 24, 2009 at 04:26 AM EST

birdsofsafeather - You may not like the way Shawn dances, but there are many of us who do. And we have just has much a right to express our opinion as you do. So, lighten up and get over yourself.

birdsofafeather Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:26 PM EST

and oh yes, Terry Hatcher did a superb job in the coaching department, Terry said Melissa was working it good, ARE YOU ALL PROFESSIONAL ACTRESSES??? NO~~~~~ I would say Terry did a 30 point coaching to Melissa

birdsofafeather Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:21 PM EST

I agree with William, Tony's A.Tango should be nominated for an award! Julianne did not win when she was nominated but I believe Tony would~~~~~~~~~

birdsofafeather Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:16 PM EST

OMG how old are the SHAWN fans bit*hing on this page????? ALL YOU KNOW HOW TO DO IS Bit*h if she doesn't get the score YOU think she deserves~~~~~~~~~ YOU SHAWN fans also think that the judges are your employees therefore they must answer to YOU~~~~~ NOT SOOOOOO!~~~~~~~~~

I will tell you~~~~Shawn does not move feminine, she is very masculine in her movements. HER core is very THICK preventing her from making gracefull movements as dance requires~~~~~ Shawn looks and moves like a MAN!!!!!!! So shut up your wining we're tired of it~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Glen Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 07:31 PM EST

I agree, the reason Gilles is injuring himself more than the other front-runners,this doesn't come too easy for him.He has to work and perform harder than the other couples to keep up.Melissa is a dancer.,,Look at the difficulty of their lifts and flexibility?Do you think Gilles and Lil Kim can compete with that?How about levelling the playing field?Shawn has a great flexibility and rhythm from her gymnastic training.This is very unfair for the none performers before the show.

Iya Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 07:22 PM EST

Picking on Gilles posture?How about a shoulder separation CAnne?You were all praised with Ty, did you look closely his rerun of his dance?Nowhere close to Gilles.I would feel bad for Gilles if the judges manipulate the whole competition over the other couples.He is the most deserving of the mirror ball and this is all what the whole competition is all about.Learning everything from the show, with no dancing background or training to his advantage.Be fair.

Sharon Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 07:17 PM EST

I disagree with you calling Tony and Melissa the best A. Tango in the history of the show.There was no passion and enough drama,all footwork and lifts.A.Tango is about a story between 2 people, they have to have the best emotional connection and the passion and intensity are the main element of the dance.Difference from a Ballroom tango is the emotional connection between the couple.Melissa was enormously lacking on that element.Listen to Len, he knows what he is talking about.

Iya Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 07:12 PM EST

Aren't you judges getting a little too tough on Gilles rcently?Do you even realize that he is going through a severe shoulder separation and will be needing a surgery soon right after the competition?I know it is about improving more each week, but how about a little consideration with what he is dealing with right now?He has proven enough for the first five weeks; blowing each of the competition out of the water, until the shoulder injury got worsen.I think it is unfair, he is the only contender with no dancing training and with a serious injury and still keeping up with the ringers, why not give him the credit for it?In your heart Carrie Ann, who do you think really deserve it?Melissa has been dancing all her life, very inconsistent and she just doesn't have the x factor at all.She only does well on dances that requires difficult lifts, because of her extensive trining on lifting for being a cherleader for so many years.Don't u think it's rather unfair for Gilles have hgher expection

Carolyn Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 04:02 PM EST

My mother mentioned that she thinks the male celebrities should watch Derek to learn how to dance like men. She doesn't think the female professionals are doing a good enough job teaching the men how to lead. I'm wondering what you think about that.

JossieM Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 03:35 PM EST

To that John guy: We feel sorry you exist too. And newsflash, EVERYONE is entitled to their own opinion. Yeah, even you. That's what BLOGGING is for.

Becca Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 02:28 PM EST

Hi Carrie Ann, I was just curious if you ever watch videos of the performances after the fact and if so does it ever change your initial reactions? Thanks

William Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 01:00 PM EST

THANK YOU CAI FOR RECOGNIZING TONY D. TALENT. HE'S NOT WORLD AND US CHAMP FOR NOTHING. TONY AND MELISSA A.TANGO WAS THE BEST OF THE SEASON AND DESERVES AN EMMY AWARD.

John Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 12:25 PM EST

What a bunch of nutcases you have commenting on your blog. As I sit here skimming through them, I can't help but feel sorry for their existence. When you all become professional dancers and choreographers, and are asked to be a judge on one of the biggest shows on television - then, and only then, will your opinions matter. Go back to your couch and pick the cheetos out of your cushions.

Felicia234 Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 11:05 AM EST

Congratulations Carrie Ann! You probably made the DUMBEST statement in the history of your show. Saying Tony and Melissa's Argentine Tango was the best so far. One word for you gf, TIVO. Review Gilles and Chery's Tango and THEN say that again. And I quote "Holy Cow! Jeez Louise!" I REST MY CASE.

JossieM Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:52 AM EST

Dry humping is right! And don't forget chuck's infamous "boobsqueeze" during their last dance. I was cringing just watching it. Very classy! (insert sarcasm)

crimson Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:46 AM EST

I thought that Shawn deserved a 30 on her Cha Cha!! It was fantastic!! A 9 was not good.. :( As for Melissa, she should have gotten a 27.

JossieM Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:42 AM EST

Apparently Chuck's posture (which did not get commented upon) is better than Gilles' (which according to you needed improvement). WOW! Hell must have frozen over.....

Heather Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:25 AM EST

I thought you were the one who hit her head last week with praise to Chuck & Julianne with their dry humping. Now, you're giving the same scores to them as Gilles & Cheryl. It's like giving your only credits as a "FLY GIRL". YOUR A HUFFSAID...

Heather Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:23 AM EST

I thought you were the one who hit her head last week with praise to Chuck & Julianne with their dry humping. Now, you're giving the same scores to them as Gilles & Cheryl. It's like giving your only credits as a "FLY GIRL". YOUR A HUFFSAID...

McG Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 10:08 AM EST

Carrie Ann -- are you all judging the dancers one against the other or each one within itself? Is each couple judged on their own merit in each performance or against how well someone else may have done the same night? I would think it is the latter. Gilles did have problems with his posture this week and Chuck made a believer out of me this week. Each should be awarded scores (as they were) on their own merit. Right?? Those at the top are working just as hard to stay there as those at the bottom to get there. THAT is what makes the show so exciting. The "lower-hanging fruit" has now dropped from the tree and everyone has to bring their A-GAME. Once Chuck got over himself he did a great job!! I'm fascinated by the pros and how they teach their partners to SHINE.

MichaelG. Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 07:56 AM EST

Dear Carrie Ann, please tell us what Shawn has to do so that you will give her a 10. Her Rumba and Cha Cha Cha were fantastic but you gave her lower scores than those who made mistakes. We know Shawn is not your favorite but can you please at least not make your double-standard that obvious? Thanks.

Roz@home Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 07:49 AM EST

Hey carrie ann, do you watch your shows after they've aired? If not then please do so. It'll be a huge wake up call and a massive uh-oh moment. Saying things like "Best Tango" about a totally mechanical, unemotional dance is a surefire way to get people riled up because it TOTALLY INSULTS OUR INTELLIGENCE. You must think we're blind or something. we might not have your resume, give us credit for recognizing good
dancers and good choreography. Stop making dumb**s statements like that because you will get called on them.

Cinders Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 06:53 AM EST

Please, Carrie Ann, it is totally insulting that you all gave Chuck, a clearly inferior dancer (poor posture, bad feet) with Gilles. And you nitpick Gilles on his posture. Please, you all are just trying to push a dead horse in Chuck to try and make it more competitive. Lil Kim's jive was so not a jive and you give her a 10. You are bordering on being ridiculous.

annie Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 06:37 AM EST

I must say that your judgement sucks this season carrie ann. Mellisa's A tango the best? Duh. Puhleez. How soon did you forget gilles and cheryls, The most moving A Tango EVER!
I understand if you wanted to shake up the leaderboard but chuck having the same score as Gilles is just waaaaaayyyyy overboard. No way has he improved that much. Insulting your viewers' intelligence isn't going to make your judgement more credible.

Yvonne Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 02:56 AM EST

What an amazing season! This year's DWTS has me on the edge of my seat! Until this week I have been rooting for Lil Kim. Now I just can't decide who I like the best. I really enjoyed watching Chuck and Julianne's performance, Melissa's footwork was so precise it was incredible! Each of the couples was so amazing to watch this week. What an improvement for Ty..at least this week! Carrie Ann, I know nothing about ballroom dancing and I find you a huge pool of information. You consistently offer valuable insight and feedback to the dancers. In fact, all three of you DWTS judges are perfectly matched for the show. I love DWTS, I can't get enough!

Alicia Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 01:23 AM EST

I loved Shawn's Cha Cha!! I thought it was the most fun and technical dance of the night. Why no 10, Carrie Ann??? Melissa was second best; her turns were off again and I didn't believe her chemistry with Tony but I think she did a good job anyways. Not a 10 worthy though. Chuck broke out of his shell and did a good job, but I think that Julianne was more in the spotlight. All the other couples were not so great. Gilles really messed up quite a bit on his V.Waltz. Very sad... I would have given him a 24.

Kasandra Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 01:19 AM EST

I don't understand why you did not give Shawn a 10. Shawn's Cha Cha more more technically superior than all of the other couples because of her flawless precision and footwork. Melissa was not flawless in her footwork, she had a few blunders and her turns were off. I thought she lacked emotion. A 9 would have been best. Gilles had posture problems, footwork problems and arm extension problems. I notice that when he extends his arms, he looses elegance because his hands are almost in latin position, which is a no-no is a standard ballroom dance. His arms were not smooth, but more abrupt like a Karate chop. He also seems to perform his dance with so much anger. This elegant dance needs to be elegant, not angry like the Paso Doble. Lil'Kim had so many balancing mistakes in her turns, leg extensions and her rumba walks. She was technically off the whole way through, yet still scores a 9. I think that judging is very difficult to do for you, but I hope that you keep some of this in mind.

anonymous Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 12:51 AM EST

Melissa's AT was "by far" the best AT of the season?

You are insufferable. You vote off your emotions, not anything valid, and you've decided to judge Gilles differently than the other dancers. Lil Kim you judge viscerally, PERIOD. And even then barely care what she does, her default is a nine for you.

Gilles gets a fine tooth comb. Bye perfect tango - Melissa's deserved a 39.

By far was an insult but sure revealed the agenda of the next two weeks. Shake up the leaderboard whether warranted or not.

JenniferW Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 12:48 AM EST

Please Carrie Ann. No "corrections" to Lil Kim for no jive in her jive and other technical failings in the rumba and the non-jive. But you nitpick Gilles?

The leaderboard isn't shaking up organically, the judges (except Len) are using double standards and games. Your own double standards are absurd. Lil Kim versus Shawn is particularly egregious. Shawn must be perfect to get 10. Lil Kim can have unsteady technique in one, and not do the dance in the other, but the only deduction she gets for unsteady technique is to get a nine, and not doing a dance gets a ten.

But you get all prissy and purse-mouthed about Gilles and the standards for the season.

so transparent.

chatz Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 12:26 AM EST

TO D ONE WHO COMMENTED THAT GILLES TANGO IS AMATEURISH, R U CRAZY? OR JUST PLAIN DUMB?

chatz Thu, Apr 23, 2009 at 12:26 AM EST

TO D ONE WHO COMMENTED THAT GILLES TANGO IS AMATEURISH, R U CRAZY? OR JUST PLAIN DUMB?

Obie Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 11:39 PM EST

Carrie Ann - Please tell all of us Shawn and Mark fans why you did not award them a 10. You stated that their technique was a precise as ever and that Shawn really let loose in the dance. What was missing from their Cha Cha that they did not achieve a perfect score? I am a little surprised this year because in years past you always have seemed to appreciate Mark's dynamic and creative choreography.

Elizabeth Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 11:00 PM EST

Hands down, the best dance of the night was Shawn and Mark's Cha Cha. Mark is the best dancer on the show and kudos to Shawn for keeping up with him. I have watched their dance on you tube at least twenty times and can't get enough of it.

jezebel Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 10:52 PM EST

I am wondering how the judges came up with 3 9s for both Chuck and Gilles. I think Chuck made an improvement, but to compare the 2 with the same scores is unbelievable. Chuck was pigeoned toed and still looks goofy. What an insult to Gilles who hasn't had an off night since the 1st dance. If you nit pick one shouldn't you nitpick the other?

Sara Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 08:38 PM EST

I guess what CA is saying is that, to her, the theatrics and character of the dance is what makes it pop, whereas other judges (like Len), it can be the technique.
What I don't think is far, however, is that Lil' Kim and Derek perform a dance that had hardly any jive elements but a lot of theatrics and they get a 10 from CA and a standing O, whereas Shawn had the technique, the character, the hip action - everything on Monday, and it only merits a 9 from CA. After that, I doubt CA will ever gve Shawn a 10.
But, it's different strokes for different folks. It will be the fans who ultimately decide. So just keep voting! The judges obviously are very qualified and have their own opinions, but we as fans have to support as well.

rose Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 08:33 PM EST

Hi there, I want invite you to my black-white community: _____ interracialconnect. c o m _____to meet some new people or find a date.

Linda Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 08:32 PM EST

Lacey and Dmitry fizzled. Did not like them together at all. It was too fast and did not reflect any togetherness. The chemistry was non existent.

Jane Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 07:24 PM EST

He spells his name Dmitry....

Kevin Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 06:59 PM EST

Shawn Johnson was the best of the night for me!! She really had a breakthrough, however, I thought she deserved another 10 at least. :(

TCG Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 06:23 PM EST

To HIITHERE - Gilles and Melissa's A. Tango were both great. Cheryl and Gilles' A. Tango DID NOT look amateurish. Gilles looked like a pro and he doesn't even have any dance experience.

Erica Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 06:12 PM EST

Melissa and Tony owned the night. That was by far the best and most intricate tango of the season. Kudos to both of them! Loved Shawn and Mark, too!

Natalia Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 06:10 PM EST

I loved Melissa and Tony's tango. Melissa is a great dancer and Tony is my favorite pro. Hope they win!

birdsofafeather Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:57 PM EST

Oh yes, if only SYTYCD pros were on dwts, that would be boring as well, you might as just call the show SYTYCD-DWTS!! A mix is needed and NOT ALL RUSSIAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!

birdsofafeather Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:55 PM EST

Yes, when I have a fav dancer and they disappointment me I want to blame the judges. IF Len, CA, Bruno, sit there week after week and were boring, then you would say replace them they are boring, but when they try to keep your attention, you say replace them, Geezzzz, Samatha is boring enough, PLEAE REPLACE SAM, TOM DOESN'T Deserve to have to host along side a box of rocks.

birdsofafeather Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:43 PM EST

Sunny, YOU TOOK THE COMMENT ABOUT MELISSA TOOOOOOOO FAR!!!!!!!!! you NEED TO APOLOGIZE TO Melissa~~~~~~~ You must be the HOHOHO!!!!!!!!!! Melissa has done nothing wrong!!!!! SHE INFACT DANCED A VERY DIFFICULT AND BEAUTIFUL TANGO~~~~~~~~~~She is the best dancer their~~~~~~~~~~~ IF FOOTBALL PLAYERS ARE STARS????WHY ARE NO THE CHEERLEADERS??????~~~~ IS AMERICA slanted one way???????? Melissa's costume was gorgeous and first class!!!!!!!!!!!! Melissa did ALL her choreography GREAT!!!!!!!

Trania Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:34 PM EST

Carrie Ann:
PLEASE stop being a fan in the way you jump up and down and wave your arms and give the contestants a hug and yell and scream when they do a dance that you love. It's very unprofessional. You are a judge, act like a judge, and don't act like a sex-crazed teenager! It just seems like you are jealous and wish you could be dancing out there with some of the hot men.

Rachel Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:24 PM EST

Thank you again for blogging, Carrie Ann! I just have to say how much I enjoyed this week. The dances were fun and the group dance was awesome. I was wondering if we're going to see a dance with all the pros this season, like you've done to kick off seasons past. I really enjoy those.

aquellas historias Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:21 PM EST

Hello! If you want to see more stories of ordinary people just visit this blog! You´ll like it!
Is http://aquellashistorias.wordpress.com Thank you!

Teresa Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 05:19 PM EST

I thought that Lacy and Demitri were great last night, but the couple that danced with The Celtic Woman were totally awesome!

cat Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 04:59 PM EST

Down to the final 6... let the games begin! Things are getting tougher now. I thought Chuck and Jules were OK/good, but not 27 good, more like 24-25 good. I think the judges have been wanting him to be better than he actually is because of Jules, so when he did perform a little bit better this week, you all got carried away.

Finally, LT is gone. About time.

*Sunny* Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 04:48 PM EST

I agree with the last comment about Melissa. Wasn't she the hohoho who was rejected by weasel bachelor? Star? RIGHT!! Let's call her pseudo-d list wannabe celeb who's only claim to fame is public humiliation. She's nothing short of a highprice callgirl.

imababboon Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 04:46 PM EST

Melissa's got to go. She may know how to dance, but seeing her week after week with the FAKEAZZ face and big teeth make me want to throw the plasma out the window!!!

littleO Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 04:44 PM EST

Can you just fire Lacey?? She brings nothing to the show but her bad attitude!!!

Sarah D Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 04:43 PM EST

If a housekeeper cleaned my Sheila E. Autograph I would explode from the inside! Sheila E. is a Goddess!!!

CR Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:59 PM EST

Thanks for the blog. Now that we are getting down to the final dancers, things are starting to heat up... even in the comments section! Granted I wasn't seeing them live, but I thought Chuck and JA were good, but not 27 good, more like 25 good. I think the judges have been wanting him to be better than he actually is, so when he did a bit better this week, you all got carried away.

So glad LT is finally gone. He should have left the week he did the dance-off with DAG.


BP Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:55 PM EST

I was SO hoping Artem would be one of the 6 people vying for the spot next year. He's my all time fav from SYTYCD. But maybe the relationship between him and C.A. prevents him from joining full time. Boo.

Lucy Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:40 PM EST

Lacey and dmitry were amazing last night.

Kim from Texas Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:29 PM EST

I really LOVED the results show. With the professional dancers competing, it will be very high on priority list to watch. It is a really great addition to the show to see how two professionals would do these same dances.

AHS Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:21 PM EST

To TCB - Yes Melissa's AT was the best. Tony's choreo and the routine was superb. Melissa was great as well.

TCB Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:16 PM EST

I don't believe for one second that you thought Melissa's tango was better than Gilles'. Considering Cheryl is my favorite pro and I'm voting all the way for her and Gilles, I've watched their performance more times than I can count, and I've heard and seen your reaction more times than I can count. You said he looked like a professional. You went crazy for their chemistry on the floor. Yet you thought Melissa's was better? I'm not buying it. Unless you were just talking about intricate choreography and amazing lifts, but that's not what you said.

Also, it's pretty obvious for the past two weeks you all are trying to shake up the leaderboard by awarding high scores where they were not earned or nitpicking for things you didn't before. While some may think it gets boring for the same couples to lead every week, others of us don't feel that way, not when the frontrunners are earning those high scores. Please judge fairly.

MRT Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:15 PM EST

Thanks! I really enjoying reading your blog; it's so nice of you to take the time to update on what is going on and your thoughts. I agree that it is really gonna be a great competition going forward; Monday night proved that!

Appreciate you!

lcw Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:10 PM EST

How could you not mention the Celtic Women and there amazing performance of 'You Raise Me Up' They were so awsome and the dancers that danced with them. They also did some amazing things. That move at the end when he put her feet on his chest and made it look like she was standing was great. They should have had more time though. The show was so cramed with everything that the crowd had barley any time to enjoy it. The part with dr sanjay gupta and the others should have been done later in the show.

canyr12 Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:07 PM EST

Gymnastics doesn't use perfect tens anymore. It's the same as the system in figure skating, where harder moves are worth more points.

katrina Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 03:03 PM EST

I was just wondering if you ever look back on your scores and wish you could change them. i know that when i watch the dances over again i often enjoy them more or less than i originally liked them.

HIITHERE Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:59 PM EST

TONY AND MELISSA'S A.TANGO WAS FANTASTIC. CHERYL AND GILLES LOOKED AMATEURISH COMPARED TO TONY AND MELISSA'S

IAA Gilles Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:39 PM EST

NYKaren - that is such a great idea! A most improved award might be fun. Carrie Ann - what do you think? Ty would totally get it this year. . . . Last year, maybe Cody - he got a lot better as the season went on. That might be nice.

michelle Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:30 PM EST

Thanks for the great blog! Who is the new pro replacing? Any chance of getting more SYTYCD folks?

A Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:29 PM EST

Carrie Ann I have to say you really need to work on your judging. Your comments towards Gilles were completely bogus. You are now just looking for ways to keep him down. Everyone else gets away with clumsy movement and gets 9's yet they dance brilliantly each week and get the same?? You've also been playing the same game with Shawn. Also Gilles and Cheryl's A. Tango was much better than Tony and Melissas. Nice Try Carrie Ann.

Lorie Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:25 PM EST

Thanks for the blog! Last night's results show was packed with good stuff. The guest dancers were amazing. It'll be fun, but hard, to pick the new pro dancer. They're all so good!

linusmom Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:22 PM EST

Thanks for the great blog Carrie Ann. Just wondering if you sensed Derek's frustration with Len this season. Len seems to call him out after every performance and not to the other pros. It makes me sad that Len has made Derek question his choreographing skills. JMO.

nykaren Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:20 PM EST

Carrie Anne if Ty doesn't make it, hes needs to get the most improved award. You should do this.Maybe next year. Shawn J needs more spark. I think she hides behind her partner to much. Maybe because shes to short. lol.Lets give Ty a big hand of applause this week. I wish everyone the best. Oh, I hate when we get down to the last 4. Tough choice this year. Good job Carrie Anne nice blog.

sosgemini Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 02:12 PM EST

Ughh, Carrie Ann's blogs grate. How about getting Tom to do it next season?

advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Latest Comments
Top Categories

All Categories

Blog Roll
Top Authors
Recent Posts
PopWatch Archive
May 2009
S M T W T F S
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31            

Complete Archive